by Matthew Johnson | Mar 17, 2023 | PTAB News, Trial Institution
By Hannah Mehrle and Matt Johnson – In IPR2022-01242, Director Vidal clarified that her prior guidance, which allows the Board to institute inter partes review even if the Fintiv factors favor discretionary denial first requires the Board to find that Fintiv...
by Matthew Johnson | Mar 10, 2023 | Discovery, Real Party in Interest
By Jesse Wynn, Robert Breetz, Matt Johnson – In Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. v. Netlist, Inc., the PTAB determined that a time-barred third party was not a real party in interest (“RPI”) and granted institution. IPR2022-00615, Paper 20 (Oct. 19, 2022) at 19...
by Matthew Johnson | Feb 23, 2023 | PTAB News
By Christian Roberts and Matt Johnson – On December 22, 2022, Director Kathi Vidal issued a pair of decisions in the OpenSky v. VLSI saga, dismissing OpenSky Industries LLC (“OpenSky”) and Patent Quality Assurance LCC (“PQA”) from their respective challenges of...
by Matthew Johnson | Feb 3, 2023 | Evidentiary Issues, Federal Circuit Appeal, Prior Art Issues, PTAB News
By Sue Gerber and Matt Johnson – Proof of prior art is an issue that often arises in inter partes and post grant review proceedings before the PTAB. In a recent decision, the Federal Circuit explained the quantum of proof that is required to establish prior...
by Matthew Johnson | Feb 2, 2023 | Estoppel, PTAB News
By Misti Blount and Matt Johnson – Director Vidal’s sua sponte Director Review decision of Apple Inc. v. Zipit Wireless, Inc. (IPR2021-01124, -01125, -01126, -01129) was recently designated as precedential. The decision dealt an immediate setback for Apple and...